
For all the factors that can affect the final price of a domain purchase or sale, it still comes down to a unique agreement between two parties.
Your domain may have all the traffic in the world, high conversion rates and a big fat upward trend surrounding it. It may be the best ExactMatch.com in the big money niche. Still –
A domain is worth what someone will pay for it.
Investment bankers and the big companies that gobble domains (Demand Media, Internet Brands, Bankrate, QuinStreet, medical conglomerates) will regale you with their ‘process’ of valuation.
Key factors?
- Organic traffic
- Trend in that traffic
- Over/under monetization
- Domain strength (i.e. Exact match? .com?)
- Clean SEO
- Competing sites
That’s important stuff to consider and to know, yes. But there’s so much more that affects how much one party will pay another for a domain. Largely, these are factors that are out of your control.
Things like:
- Is your niche hot?
- Have competing sites been bought already/recently? By who?
- Is VC money flowing in to your niche?
- Is someone trying to go public, so they’re buying up domains like hotcakes?
This list could go on forever. The point is, with so much that’s decidedly out of your control, can you ever sit there and place a dollar value on your site? Can you reasonably expect to sell it any time you get the urge?
No and no. A domain is only worth what someone will pay for it, at a specific time, if you’re lucky. It’s got so much more to do with the unpredictable factors than the ones you can control.
Talking from Experience
On the selling side, we’ve sold 2 “companies” that were akin to selling “domains”. Both were sold to buyers who were looking to add assets (read: traffic, properties) with an eye on going public or getting acquired themselves.
The price we were paid was more about them managing their budget and expectations of a future payout on their end, rather than anything we created consciously with our business.
The acquiring companies got bought and went public, respectively, and now our old properties are on the sale block. Our achievement was simply a means to an end for someone else’s purpose.
Buying
We buy domains all the time. You know how we price them? Might as well be a dart board. Seriously.
I think $25,000 is a sweet number to ballpark a great domain that is currently doing nothing and could become a real business. So that’s where we start. No idea where this came from. It’s just what I’ll pay for a domain.
Other buyers on the market are just as likely to have obscure, unscientific reasoning behind what they offer you. We were offered $1 million for a domain a few weeks ago, and it had nothing to do with some multiple of revenue or a trending market. The offer had more to do with the buyer’s desire to accumulate assets, and leverage other related properties in the mortgage and lead-gen space.
See? Right there, the offer doesn’t have anything to do with the investment banker checklist. We couldn’t chase it intentionally. We wouldn’t get the same offer from anyone else, competitor or otherwise.
The domain is worth what someone – some 1 – will pay for it.
It’s Dangerous out There
This makes for a proverbial field of landmines for most domain owners.
So many questions arise about how to price a domain you’re buying, how to trust the other party, how to gauge the potential, etc. When selling, there’s questions of seeking professional counsel and the buy vs. hold arguments that go through your head. It’s rough.
The best advice I can give you is to talk to people who’ve done it before. You can pickup some lessons learned the hard way, and try to apply it to the situation at hand.
Every single domain sale in history is a different situation, though. What Johns Wu did isn’t what Shane Pike did, it isn’t what we did, it’s not what you’ll do.
Takeaway
In buying and selling domains, there’s no blueprint. It’s a freaking blank canvas, so proceed accordingly. Go off your instincts. Don’t bank on building a site only to sell it. Too much is out of your control.
Images: Hibb08 and Leona Shanana










